Cases & Science

Editorial scientific cases and de-identified scenario analyses to understand clinical reasoning.

Complex Knee Pain With Conflicting Imaging Findings

Case Context (De-identified)

Adult patient presenting with persistent knee pain and functional limitation following prior conservative management. MRI findings suggest degenerative changes; clinical examination indicates possible mechanical instability.

Clinical Question

Should surgical intervention be considered, or should conservative management be extended given conflicting indicators?

Reasoning Summary

Imaging findings alone suggested age-related degeneration; however, clinical instability and patient-reported functional limitation indicated mechanical involvement beyond imaging severity. Differential considerations included meniscal pathology versus ligament laxity not fully captured on MRI.

Decision Paths Considered

  • Continued conservative management with physiotherapy
  • Diagnostic arthroscopy
  • Surgical intervention with alignment correction

Rejected Options

Extended conservative management was deprioritized due to declining functional status and mechanical symptoms inconsistent with imaging-only pathology.

Final Review Outcome

Surgical evaluation recommended following second-opinion review.

Unknowns

Long-term functional outcome given mixed degenerative and mechanical findings.

Post-Traumatic Nasal Deformity With Airway Compromise

Case Context (De-identified)

Adult patient with prior nasal trauma presenting with chronic obstruction and cosmetic asymmetry.

Clinical Question

Can functional correction be achieved without compromising structural stability?

Reasoning Summary

Airway obstruction correlated with septal deviation and internal valve collapse. Cosmetic correction required careful balancing to avoid worsening airflow.

Decision Paths Considered

  • Functional septoplasty alone
  • Combined functional and structural reconstruction

Rejected Options

Isolated cosmetic correction rejected due to risk of persistent obstruction.

Final Review Outcome

Combined functional-structural approach supported.

Unknowns

Postoperative airflow adaptation variability.